top of page

Great Marketing Doesn't Always Find You. Sometimes You Stumble Across It.

Writer: Brian Fallers
Brian Fallers
Oct 27
4 min read

An unexpected lesson in authenticity, storytelling, and brand experience on the streets of New York City.


Wide-angle view of a New York City street wall covered with repeated NikeCraft DEMERITS advertising posters promoting the Tom Sachs shoe collaboration.

My wife and I recently spent a couple of days in New York City. No packed agenda. No business meetings. Just an opportunity to get away, spend some time together, explore the city, and enjoy everything that makes New York, well, New York.


Of course, after spending most of my career in marketing, branding, and customer experience, it's almost impossible for me to completely turn that part of my brain off.


And frankly, I don't really want to.


I've always believed some of the best lessons in marketing aren't found in boardrooms, research reports, or industry conferences. They're found in the experiences happening all around us.


Sometimes, quite literally, on the street.


While walking through the city, I came across a gentleman plastering a wall with what seemed like an endless series of identical posters. Old school marketing at its finest.


One shoe. One word.


DEMERITS.



I stopped.


Not because I was looking for a new pair of shoes. Not because I recognized the campaign. But because something about it demanded my attention.


The posters featured a NikeCraft shoe created in collaboration with artist Tom Sachs. The story behind it was even more interesting than the creative.


As a high school student, Sachs nearly got expelled for wearing soccer shoes instead of the required black dress shoes. Rather than conform, he colored over the white Nike Swoosh with a marker.


What was once an act of teenage defiance became the inspiration for a Nike shoe decades later.


And there it was. An authentic origin story transformed into a product, a message, and an experience. No flashy digital screens. No elaborate production. No sophisticated technology.


Just paper, paste, repetition, and a story worth telling.


Why did it work?


Because it wasn't simply advertising a shoe.

It was expressing an identity.


The word demerits is provocative. The visual is stark. The repetition creates impact. And the story gives the entire experience meaning.


It challenges conformity while celebrating individuality and creative expression.


And the execution itself reinforces the message. There is something appropriately rebellious about seeing these posters plastered across a gritty New York City wall rather than displayed in a polished retail environment.


The medium becomes part of the message.


There's another interesting dimension here. In my book, The Authenticity Blueprint, I frequently reference Nike as one of the ultimate examples of the Hero archetype, a brand built on overcoming obstacles, challenging limitations, and achieving what once seemed impossible. But even the Hero has room for a little Outlaw. Sometimes challenging limits means challenging the rules themselves. That's what makes this campaign so compelling. Nike hasn't abandoned its identity. It's simply tapped into a more rebellious side of it. And because that rebellion is grounded in an authentic story, it feels entirely natural.


The connection to authenticity


At Oath & Origins, we spend a great deal of time helping organizations understand who they are, what they stand for, and how those truths translate into experiences that people actually believe. We talk about the relationship between an organization's origin, its promise, and the experiences that bring both to life.


This campaign brought that thinking into focus for me.


The origin was real.

The identity was unmistakable.

And the execution stayed true to both.


That's what makes the difference between simply communicating a message and creating a meaningful brand experience.


And it reminded me of something else.


We spend an extraordinary amount of time in marketing discussing platforms, channels, technology, optimization, and increasingly, artificial intelligence.


All important. All valuable. But sometimes we overlook the most fundamental question:


Are we creating something worth paying attention to?


That afternoon in New York, a wall covered in posters accomplished exactly that. It caught my attention, sparked my curiosity, and made me want to learn more.


And now I'm writing about it.

That's a pretty remarkable outcome for some paper and paste.


Great marketing doesn't always require more complexity. Sometimes it just requires greater clarity, an authentic story, and the courage to express it differently.


And sometimes, the best marketing inspiration comes when you're not looking for it.



About the Author

Brian Fallers is the founder of Oath & Origins, a marketing, brand, and experience design partner helping organizations build authentic brands, align culture with experience, and create clarity that drives sustainable growth.


A seasoned marketing and brand executive, strategist, and advisor, Brian has spent his career helping organizations of all sizes translate their unique identities into meaningful brand experiences and business results.


He is also the bestselling author of The Authenticity Blueprint, which explores the intersection of authenticity, psychology, culture, leadership, and brand experience, and how organizations can turn what makes them genuinely different into a competitive advantage.


Learn more at OathandOrigins.com or explore TheAuthenticityBlueprint.com. To purchased the The Authenticity Blueprint, visit https://a.co/d/0fFTGYUH.


About Oath & Origins

Oath & Origins (O2) is a marketing, brand, and experience design partner built around a different model. Part strategic consultancy, part creative agency, and part executive-level marketing partner, O2 brings together seasoned leadership, specialized expertise, and creative capabilities to help organizations achieve greater clarity, differentiation, and sustainable growth.


Blending the strategic depth of a consultancy with the creativity and execution of an agency, O2 helps organizations connect brand, culture, marketing, customer experience, and employee experience into a cohesive business strategy.


Powered by decades of experience working with startups, emerging businesses, private equity-backed organizations, and some of the world's most recognized brands, O2 brings enterprise-level thinking and capabilities to organizations of all sizes.


Through VeridigmTM, its proprietary culture- and science-based Business Experience Intelligence system, O2 combines human insight with intelligence-guided strategy to uncover authentic organizational identity and translate it into meaningful experiences.


Others chase momentum. We design clarity that sustains growth.


Learn more at OathandOrigins.com.

© 2026 by Oath & Origins

bottom of page